The comparison at a glance
| Sole trader | Limited company | |
|---|---|---|
| Liability | Unlimited — personal assets exposed | Limited to the company (bar guarantees) |
| Tax | Income tax + NI on all profits, yearly | Corporation Tax; then tax when extracted — timing control |
| Admin | Self Assessment; MTD quarterly updates if over threshold | Accounts, CT600, confirmation statement, payroll |
| Privacy | Nothing public | Accounts, officers and PSCs on the public register |
| Perception | Fine for most trades | Preferred/required by many corporate clients and agencies |
How the tax actually differs
A sole trader pays income tax and National Insurance on all profits in the year they arise — whether or not the money is needed personally. A company pays Corporation Tax (19–25%) on profits, and the owner then pays tax only on what they extract as salary or dividends. That second layer is why a company isn’t automatically cheaper — but the control is the point: profit can be retained at Corporation Tax rates, taken in a lower-income year, or put into a pension with full relief.
The admin comparison — post-MTD
Sole traders’ admin is rising: MTD for Income Tax brings digital records and quarterly updates for those over the thresholds (£50,000 from April 2026, £30,000 from 2027, £20,000 from 2028). Companies were never in MTD for Income Tax but file more by default: statutory accounts, a CT600, a confirmation statement, and payroll if salary is taken. Either way, the era of one January tax return and nothing else is ending — the question is which set of obligations suits you.
Deciding for real
The honest method: project a year’s profit, decide how much you need to live on, and compare total tax + admin cost under each structure — then weigh liability and client expectations, which often decide it regardless of a small tax difference. We run this comparison with real numbers as part of company formation support, and we’ll tell you plainly if staying a sole trader is the better answer. Call 0114 327 1480.
Frequently asked questions
Related
Need help with Making Tax Digital?
Ask us anything about MTD, or request that we register or file for you. Call 0114 327 1480 or send a message below.